| 2026 |
Jared Fiske, Men's Soccer |
Sophia Bailey, Women's Rugby |
| 2025 |
Duncan Keker, Men's Soccer |
Tova Gelb, Women's Basketball |
| 2024 |
Owen Fauth, Men's Soccer |
Hailey Brigger, Field Hockey |
| 2023 |
Gavin van Beveren, Men's Volleyball |
Augusta Stockman, Women's Cross Country and Track and Field |
| 2022 |
Jack Casalino, Men's Cross Country and Track and Field |
Jesse Ecklund, Women's Swimming and Diving |
| 2021 |
David Ganham, Men's Tennis |
Frances Cornwall, Women's Tennis |
| 2020 |
Mattie Mrlik, Men's Soccer |
Sophie Nick, Women's Basketball |
| 2019 |
Tyler Gilmore, Men's Soccer |
Devan Gallagher, Women's Volleyball |
| 2018 |
Matthew Knigge, Men's Volleyball |
Kate Christensen, Women's Tennis |
| 2017 |
Nick Litsky, Men's Tennis |
Julia Cunningham, Women's Swimming and Diving |
| 2016 |
Noah Parson, Men's Lacrosse &
Taylor Vann, Men's Track and Field |
Catilin Drakeley, Women's Basketball |
| 2015 |
Luc Amodio, Men's Swimming and Diving |
Heather Ingraham, Women's Track and Field |
| 2014 |
Juliano Pereira, Men's Soccer |
Cydni Matsuoka, Women's Basketball |
| 2013 |
Zander Mrlik, Men's Soccer & Baseball |
Kelly Holmes, Women's Cross Country and Track and Field |
| 2012 |
Nick Johnson, Men's Fencing |
Brittany Parks, Women's Basketball |
| 2011 |
Andrew Fischl, Men's Fencing |
Sarah Warner, Women's Lacrosse |
| 2010 |
Phil Tully, Men's Volleyball |
Nicole Pontee, Women's Tennis |
| 2009 |
John Kessenich, Men's Volleyball |
Emily Love, Women's Swimming and Diving |
| 2008 |
Lawrence Avitabile, Men's Basketball |
Christine Castellan, Women's Lacrosse |
| 2007 |
Court Steiner, Men's Soccer |
Debbie Sharnak, Women's Tennis |
| 2006 |
Justin Bernstein, Men's Fencing |
Anita Slavin, Women's Volleyball |
| 2005 |
Avi Kramer, Men's Cross Country |
Kaitlin Harvie, Field Hockey and Women's Lacrosse |
| 2004 |
Tim Reinhardt, Baseball |
McKenzie Johnson, Women's Volleyball and Rowing |
| 2003 |
Steven Money, Men's Cross Country |
Devon Chen, Women's Swimming and Diving |
| 2002 |
David Paine, Men's Volleyball |
Lisa Ercolano, Women's Basketball |
| 2001 |
Stefan Bussey, Men's Rowing |
Lauren Jones, Women's Tennis |
| 2000 |
Josh Beauregard, Men's Basketball |
Clodagh Rafferty, Women's Cross Country |
| 1999 |
James McCowan, Men's Cross Country |
Ali Dorris, Women's Soccer |
| 1998 |
Anton Briggs, Men's Lacrosse |
Rachel Bartfield, Women's Volleyball |
| 1997 |
Caleb Wilkinson, Men's Basketball |
Molly Moran, Field Hockey |
| 1996 |
John Chasey, Men's Volleyball |
Kristen Vogt, Women's Basketball |
| 1995 |
Joe Davidyock, Men's Soccer |
Anya Bailis, Women's Swimming and Diving |
| 1994 |
Carlos Cortes, Men's Swimming and Diving |
Austen Barron, Women's Squash |
